Am I being too picky?

I brewed a 12 gallon batch of Kolsch today.  I’m not used to my new 20 gallon kettle, so I had more boil-off than expected.  My O.G. is 1.060 rather than the 1.050 I was shooting for.  Do I dilute the wort down with some water to get a lower gravity for what I want to be a session beer, or should I RDWHAHB?

I would dilute a bit.  It’s not a hop driven style, so a little hop utilization loss wouldn’t hurt badly, and it would bring the gravity down to a more average strength, which is desireable for Kolsch.  But you know, I’ve done both in the past.  You’ll make good beer either way.

Needless to say, RDWHAHB !

I’m thinking about a 1/2 gallon in each carboy should take it into the 1054-1.055 range.

Sounds like a winner.  I bet it’ll be tasty.

I don’t think you are being too picky and I’ve done the same thing before.

Been there, done that.

But I know I’m picky.  8)