I think it’s safe to assume it’s for a malt-forward, amber-colored ale. So I assume the question relates to whether this water profile is still appropriate when adding pumpkin and/or spice. For instance, would the higher sulfate content of a hoppy profile be appropriate to ephasize the spice addition, as it does for hops? I say go with malty.
I assumed it to be a Bru’nWater question Kyle, so since most pumpkin ales are amber, malt (and spice) forward beers, with restrained hoppiness, that the Amber Malty profile in Bru’nWater would be appropriate.