Okay, thanks! Also going to be my first attempt at dry hopping, so I didn’t have much experience to go off of.
I was basically just using the sugar as an easy(lazy?) way to increase the gravity since I tend to have a low mash efficiency (something I should probably address). Also since it’s my first attempt at a recipe, I was using the BeerSmith style guidelines and essentially just shooting for the middle
My IPA grain bill is similar to yours other than it has 1/2# of sugar and I use honey malt and a bit more munich. I get great results. I don’t see a problem with the sugar but #1 might be a bit much.
Had to pivot my initial plan on this recipe, since my LHBS didn’t have 10 lb bags of pale malt in stock, so I switched to Maris Otter as my base malt. I guess this is a little fortunate, because I’ve been wanting to play with Maris Otter a bit and this gave me a good reason. I was also tossing up whether to use pale malt or Maris Otter when I started writing this recipe down.
The other change I was thinking about making is scrapping the crystal malt altogether, and adding a pound of cara-pils to increase head retention in the final beer. Wondering if anyone has any personal experience with whether that actually helps, or if a pound of it is even necessary at this size batch.
I’m not a big Crystal fan, but in this beer and at that proportion I would keep it as a rock to help balance the sweetness side of the scale. Others may feel differently, but I would also forget the CaraPils. If you feel you need a boost for head retention, I would use 5-10% Pale Wheat, which always works for me.