;D
I’ve been keeping my eyes on this post for a few days, and it is definitely interesting to see the responses. To me, this whole idea can (should?) be broken down into two different kinds of criticisms, style and off-flavors. One of my favorite beer styles Strong Scotch ale, I just love 'em. I’ve had a lot of Scotch ales where I can definitely smell and taste peat-smoked malt, and I don’t like it. Peat in Scotch whisky? Awesome, Laphroaig is outstanding, but I think peat smoke muddies the intense malt sweetness that I love so much in Scotch ale. Would I ever go up to a commercial brewer and say, “You know, you shouldn’t add peated malt to your scotch ale”? Absolutely not, because I know my tastes don’t suit everyone. On the other hand, if I could taste rubbing alcohol in a Scotch ale, that’s a different question and maybe something needs to be said. But I still don’t know if I would say anything because the pros who brewed probably have more experience tasting beer than I do, so maybe they already know something went wrong with their fermentation.
Under the right circumstances, “that guy” could be helpful in recognizing fatal flaws in beer that may have gone unnoticed, but “that guy” could also become a nuisance by describing “flaws” in a beer that simply reflect personal tastes. Stone’s Arrogant Bastard proudly states “You will not like this beer”, and I’m sure a lot of people don’t, but the recipe isn’t going to change.
Now that is always a fun topic to disagree about. 
Football is right around the corner. Cardinals and Saints play on August 5th. Almost time to start another football thread. 
In order for “that guy” to be helpful, he’d have to actually taste the beer…which he didn’t. Given that, any comments he made had nothing to back them up.
i agree with all this. my point is that it just because he is not a pro doesn’t mean he can’t make valid observations. in this case maybe not so valid. i do agree that it is all in the way he may have presented this hence i would refer to “that guy” in this instance as a douche. however if he had said, wow, nice take on your IIPA, but i wasn’t expecting it to be x, y, or z in nature. would it then have opened up a good conversation. I guess overall i agree with you, but my thought is that it seems like we are out of bounds criticizing pros. though i know this is not in your case because i have heard you time and again defend commercial beers Budweiser and (i think you have also defended) corona. and i agree with you there. i think this is the case mostly of how things are communicated.
Amen Major. I had a guy ask to come over and see my Brutus system, ask questions and such as he was looking to build his own. He tasted a couple of my beers and here are some of his comments to a tee…Ill never forget because I spent the evening thinking…wow I never met a homebrewer like that before. What a pompous ass.
“Clean IPA very good, but I do this in mine and its better for it”
“Youre better than 99% of the brewers I know”…me:“oh thanks man” him: “Im the 1% better though”
“Ive been brewing for 7 years I know all there is to know about brewing, hes adjusting his water for this reason, but I know all there is to know about water and I dont do it for a reason.”
to his gf: “THis is the second best pumpkin beer we’ve had huh sweety?”…his gf turns her head and takes another sip of mine and says “yeh”
Lol comical. Funny thing was, hes over in MY HOUSE asking me questions about MY SYSTEM, making these comments. Then when he left he said, maybe we can do a collaborative batch or something. Never understood people like this, if you know all there is know, then where is the fun in doing it. Get over yourself.
There is at least one guy like that in every area. We had one that I can see in my mind saying the same things.
At one point you could have said “Yeah, homebrewing is 99% asshole free”.
Its the brewery’s job to put their best foot forward. If they think I could be of help, they’ll ask my opinion. Otherwise, I’ll keep buying the beer if I like it, and vice versa if I don’t.
I’m sure “that guy” is the same guy that tells you why his political opinions are superior to yours.
We call “that guy” a “douchebag” 'round these parts.
HAH! Wish I would’ve thought of it at the time.
This
And especially THIS:
“Probrewers”
(insert eyeroll)
Don’t worry about that guy man.
Have some confidence in your product and gimme a chuckle. 8)
I guess the only thing more annoying than over-critical homebrewers is all the Dr. Phils in the room (insert eyeroll).
I’m not wringing my hands about this nor have I lost any sleep or have any issues with my self worth. I have confidence in the beer and have had my share of criticism, some fair, some not. I don’t think you guys who are on the Dr. Phil trip realize how many people I have interacted with over the two years I have been doing this. I sell beer all over the state of alabama and have met hudereds of people. I have just noticed that sometimes homebrewers can tend to be overly critical about other people’s beer: both homebrewed and commercial.
I got way more worked up about Nateo’s comments and his seeming implication that some guy who hadn’t even tried the beer could be offering some hidden gem of wisdom that I had failed to grasp more than I did over anything else.
This is why i don’t let other brewers drink my beer ;D (I am critical enough of the stuff i brew)
Wow…Just, wow.
Yeah, even if he was kidding that is total douche material. In the graphic design business we have a lot of people like that. They won’t pay you a legitimate compliment no matter what. They never become art directors, because they are so blinded by their ego that they can’t see talent.
You never asked him to come back and bring beer? Hell he must of had beer of the gods. You should get the same chance to critique his brew… hell call him tonight and ask him to come back and bring samples. Update the thread in a few days.
I cannot believe some opinionated barfly has caused a thread to go on this long.
Whiskey Tango Foxtrot? [u]Who gives a shit?[/u]
I knew the "Homebrewers (insert eyeroll) tag would catch some attention.
I thought that was the club I joined…
When I was a CFHBer I always thought we could have chosen a better logo. But talk about truth in advertising…