Paging passenger Saccharomyces, please report to the yeast subforum concourse...

Very nice!!

Wyeast 2112 and Wyeast 2035 descend from the same yeast strain; namely, the Christian Schmidt strain, so either strain should work in the sixties.  A cream ale is very close to a CAP.  I personally prefer a CAP.  A CAP fermented with Wyeast 2035 can be an amazing beer, but Wyeast 2035 can be a polarizing yeast strain.

I got sulfur from the yeast. Surely it was something I did but I’m hard pressed to pinpoint what. I pitched at about 76F, cooled to 65 and then let it sit at about 68 for 2 weeks.  It was one packet into 3 gallons of 1.048 wort so maybe this speaks to the overpitch issue??  It was the only time I ever detected sulfur in a beer, and considering I only brew ales it was an eye opener for sure.  Taste was fine, just couldn’t get past the aroma.  My guess is that I needed to get down into the upper 50’s low 60’s.

Yes Wallenpaupack Brewing is on Lake Wallenpaupack in Northeast PA.  Beautiful area.

I don’t remember Bravo being a must, so [Insert your favorite bittering hop here] should be fine.

I have listened to both of those, very good stuff.

Brewing I Dream of Jenny has been on my to-do list for a long time.

Can you explain why?  Genetically this yeast is almost identical to W-34/70 which a million brewers on the internet seem to love.

Wyeast 2035 groups with W-34/70 via an ancestor strain, but it is definitely not a perfect clone of W-34/70.  I has a distinctive ester and higher alcohol profile.  Plus, 2035 produces diacetyl at a much higher level than W-34/70. W-34/70 is fairly neutral when compared to Wyeast 2035.

Yeah, I have never thought 2035 and 2124 (34/70) were similar.  I have only used 2035 when trying to replicate something similar to Yuengling Traditional Lager and I like its character and it seems very close to what is used in the commercial version.

Mark, one more question:  Do you use a tool/calculator/site to determine how much slurry (or fresh yeast) to use in a given batch based on batch size, yeast strain, gravity, etc?  In the old days there was MrMalty.com which may still be around but I thought I looked for it recently and couldn’t find it or else the calculator was not working properly.  I make a lot of 5% lagers and I use a lot of the same strains:  Omega Bayern, 2124, 940 are very common here.  Outliers are 2308/838, Diamond and 2278.  Cheers and thanks again.

Thanks for that data.  You are correct, these are technically not identical but are more like 3rd cousins or something akin to that.  I have never used 2035, so if I can get my hands on any, I’ll play around with it to see if I get similar results.

Ah, but 2124 is not even remotely related to 2035 or W-34/70.  Genomic testing shows that 2124 is more closely related to 2206 as well as… WLP029 Kolsch!  And these groups are on branches quite distant from one another.  Ref: http://beer.suregork.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/Brewing_yeast_tree_Oct_2019.pdf

re: k-97, i fermented it around 50F and it was super clean, definitely not mistakeable for a lager, but just really clean. i detected zero sulfur aroma at any point. muted hop flavour and aroma though and it is permanently hazy unless you let it sit for a very very long time. i wish people wouldn’t discount k-97 so much.

I have some 5 month old crushed grains #5 munich and #5 pils may mash that up and throw that k-97 in give it a whirl