Yes, this is a really good book, particularly for those who want to build their own recipes. The recipes here are a great guideline when you realize you can change up the hops/grain bill to suit your tastes. Before reading this book, I never knew that late hop additions were such a big part of certain styles. I’ve used a few recipes in here as guidelines and all beers came out fantastic.
Currently subscribed to Zymurgy and BYO, generally find them interesting and informative. I’m on the forum daily and would say that this site has been the most informative and entertaining (not just for brewing) resource. It’s interesting to hear what other folks are up to and have the opportunity to learn from their struggles and success.
I have read a fair amount of books on brewing and I have subscribed to BYO for the past 4 or 5 years(still good info in it for me). I just joined aha recently and subscribed to Zymurgy and I agree completely. This forum is very informative/entertaining and the back issues of Zymurgy Ive read (now that they are online) have been fantastic. I wish I joined earlier.
I agree, when this book first came out I tried to brew just about every beer in there just to get familiar with the styles and ingridients that I might have ignored in the past. As a brewer I found myself getting into a rut and continuing to brew a few styles that I really liked and got good at over and over. This was sort of a homebrewers Julie and Julia (James and Jamil) initiative. After my first cut on each recipe I’d take tasting notes and adjust the recipe for a rebrew.
I finished the project, I’d say I got through about 65% of the recipes but I have rebrewed many of those with my tweaks. The lesson hear is that you can get very booksmart at this hobby but at some point you need to really dig in and understand your ingridients and their affect on different styles. BCS is a great tool for doing that.
I consider myself an “intermediate” brewer.
I have almost all of the above books and have learned much from them.
(BLAM and Wild Brews are not yet in my library–Hint! X-mas is coming!)
The internet is a great resource for intermediate brewers–this forum in particular. Some things just don’t make it into books but nonetheless need explaining, e.g. how to dry hop (throw it in?, use a nylon bag?), corny keg posts mixups (gas in has a gash, fluid out does not), not using highly alkaline water to make up starsan solutions (use distilled or RO instead).
My most frequent reference book is Greg Noonan’s Brewing Lager Beer (my copy doesn’t say “new”).
I also consult Jamil’s Classic Styles when making up recipes. It has very good tips.
+1. Very good points - sometimes a nugget is found by just keeping attentive to all sources. I am enjoying Gordon Strong’s Brewing Better Beers - some handy insights without belaboring the basics or getting crazy math/biology/chemistry/physics on a guy.
I have most of the books listed in the other posts, but I still pull most of my ideas and recipes from Charlies’ books. Those are almost a daily read (1 recipe at a time), and I’ve probably read those books 4-5 times over.
I’m rereading Gordon Strong’s book, and really appreciating it. I have all the basics listed above and then some. Designing Great Beers was the book that was most transformative to me after I had the basics down.
I would add Basic Brewing’s videos to the list. Well-done and clear.
I just finished reading “Yeast: The Practical Guide to Beer Fermentation” by Chris White and Jamil Zainasheff, and found it pretty interesting. It was a good read in that it not only gave information about yeast and fermentation, but it was information applicable for both pros and homebrewers, and they actually gave practical advice for both.
I’d say if you liked Gordon Strong’s BBB where he focuses on the hot side of things, “Yeast” is a good book for the cold side.