Since I didn’t see a reply from the op on m y previous suggestion, let’s just say he pulled a small final gravity sample using a refractometer instead of a hydrometer. Using sean’s calculator Refractometer Calculator « SeanTerrill.com that translates to a final gravity of 1.0012, which is decidedly dry. I’m not saying he did use a refractometer, but if he did, I think this might explain it.