Pitched at 52F and fermented the same for 5 days.
Fermenting at 55F for the last couple of days.
SG is now 1.017 and there is still a quarter inch of Krausen.
I tasted the hydro sample and I couldn’t find diacetly but it may be to sweet for me to tell.
Should I let it go in the mid 50’s or warm it up into the 60’s?
Also, should I let it completely finish before cold conditioning or leave a couple points before dropping the temp?
You are fermenting that thing way too cold. This is an ale, not a lager. I pitch mine around 56-58 and ferment around 60-62. Go ahead and warm up into the low 60s Definitely don’t lager until fermentation is 100% complete.
That’s definitely not my favorite yeast for the style, but its real sluggish below 58F. I’d recommend fermenting warmer & lagering vs. forcing a slow, cold ferment. Just my 2-cents!
The two biggest drawbacks to cold fermenting ale strains is the reduction of esters and the possibility of arrested or stuck fermentation. If you want less yeast profile then go cold but be careful you don’t crash the yeast and end up under attenuated.
So, not to nit-pick but what about this in the description: “…A pleasant, subtle fruit aroma from fermentation (apple, cherry or pear) is acceptable, but not always present…”?
you are taking that out of context. if you read through the rest of the description, I’d say you’d be hard pressed to get all of those characteristics with lager yeast. Also, despite the guidelines saying ‘not always present’ it is what most judges and drinkers are looking for, right or wrong.
IMO, this is just one of those styles where yeast strain selection can’t be compromised.
Not your favorite yeast for the style? Then what is? I like WLP029, but I think the Wy strain is great - maybe even more authentic.
+1 to Blatz comments. Kolsch has a distinctive, yet subtle, flavor to it. Kind of wine/chardonnay like finish that I haven’t ever tasted on any other beer style. That’s the key between it tasting like a kolsch and simply being a blonde ale that is called a kolsch. Too many brewpubs call their blondes “kolsch”.
IMO 2565 is superior for koelsch. 029 is too “yeasty” for lack of a better word, though a local pro brewer gets great fruit aroma from it at 64 degrees ferm, I can’t replicate it at home. I ferment koelsch at 59-60, letting it slow rise to about 66 by the end of fermentation. I get a slight cherry aroma with some peach (from sulfur, I understand) at these temps. Also, one other commercial example that we can get in NC is Sunner, but it’s HORRIBLE! Avoid it if possible…