I used to play a lot of chess tournaments. Chess pieces and sets have always fascinated me and I have quite a collection of them. My kegerator sits right under a 13x16 photo I took of my favorite wooden set. A nice chess piece handle would just fit so well with the theme of sets and trophies I have in my mancave.
+1 on making it yourself. Grab a piece of pine and get to carving! That way it’ll be the size you want and you’ll have a conversation starter in addition to your homebrew. Get yourself a dremel and it should go fairly quickly if you’re not much of a whittler.