Smoker Opinions

Looking for reviews on smokers that the community members use. I’m leaning towards electric so I can cold smoke but also interested in a propane.

Thank you in advance!!

I have a Weber Smoky Mountain. It’s a charcoal smoker so it doesn’t match your specs. But, I will say Weber makes high quality gear. I regularly abuse my smoker and my Weber gas grill by leaving the cover off and letting them get soaked in rain. Both are several years old (at least) and both have held up remarkably well.

If you’re only interested in smoking rather than fully cooking, the Little Chief or Big Chief offer the best bang for the buck. Either can be had from Amazon for around $100 if you watch for sales. These are made specifically for smoking fish, and work well for jerky, cheese and grains. They also double as a dehydrator when you want to keep the heat out of the house.

I’ve used a Little Chief for 30 years, mainly for fish.  Does a great job.

Like Tommy, I’m also a WSM fan.  It’s a very useful tool that can do it all IMO.

When I want to cool smoke something like jerky, Kielbasa, Bacon, or Summer Sausage, I simply build a line of charcoal briquettes around the fire ring. I light one end and it snakes it’s way around. It stays ~110-115*F.

I use it high heat by filling the charcoal ring and lighting a full chimney and opening up the vents for brisket, turkey, chicken, etc… I do low n slow pork butts by choking down the vents.

I’m definitely interested in fully cooking items. I want to be able to smoke at low temps for long periods at a maintainable temp w/o constantly fussy over needless adjustments, a sort of set it and forget it.

Pellet grills are another option albeit not an inexpensive one, but there are a lot of folks who love them and swear by them. When mine’s not being cranky I can smoke as low as ~150 and bake up to >350. I wouldn’t recommend the brand I purchased but I would recommend pellet grills in general, and the pellets are considerable less expensive than charcoal. I will admit though that a good charcoal grill will instill more smoke flavor than a pellet grill. I do have several charcoal smokers, but they rarely get used, more trouble and more expensive fuel.

My suggestion is an Akorn Kamado. Should be about $300. You can smoke, grill, etc. using the same smoker. Of course it is not pellet or gas, it is charcoal.

I’ve tried bullet smokers, offset firebox, gas indirect, etc. I gave away my gas grill after getting the Akorn and haven’t looked back. It does some with a learning curve, but coupled with a TipTopTemp you can dial it in and leave it.

Now if all you want is to cold smoke, I think and electric would be the best bet.

For smoking sausages, bacon, and other meats, I really like my Sausage Maker electric. But, it still doesn’t get down to real cold smoke temps. There is a port on the side that I use to hook up my own cold smoker. You can  make them pretty cheap. You still have to attend to them every couple hours.

I was looking at those. Still up in the air though. Can you tell me which model you have and any dis-likes you may have? Given the chance to purchase again, would you buy said model again?

I have a Pitboss pellet smoker that I retrofitted with a SmokeDaddy digital PID controller.  I like how it lets me set-it-and-forget-it unlike a wood or coal burner system which you have to tend continually. Electrics are set and forget too, but I can get the temp up higher so I get crispy chicken skin and better bark than I ever could  with my Masterbuilt Electric smoker.
Pellet smokers are pretty notorious for not producing as much smoke as stick burners and electric because the fire is smaller than a wood burner and its used as the heat source too.  I added an AMAZ-N tube smoker for about 20 bucks, and this issue is not an issue any more.
Plus, having the tube lets me cold smoke, too.

While I admire the “caveman” concept of stick burning, I’m happy with the ease of use of my pellet burner and the results I get with it.

Oh, and the SmokingMeatForums.com is a great resource.  They are just as friendly, informative, and into BBQ over there as we are here. Plus, they have a “Beer and Brewing” section, too.

I couldn’t respectably disagree with this more. WSM(s) are known for ‘set it and forget it’ cooking — naturally aspirated.

I had a masterbuilt electric smoker for a few years and it done an absolutely gorgeous and delicious job of smoking chicken, turkey, brisket , Boston butt etc… The smoke flavor and juicyness has been great. The best part is you set the temp and it holds it and you load in chips every hour or so.

Thanks!!

Agree 100%. I setup my Akorn smoker and don’t worry about it again until it’s time to remove the meat.

I’ve been very happy with my Traeger pellet smoker/grill.  Nice to be able to set temp and walk away.

I’ll also recommend the Akorn as the best all purpose grill you can get for the price.  Holds temp almost like a BGE, lighter, and as long as you don’t leave it out in the rain it lasts.

I will say that for smoking, you want a temperature controlled fan.  This is going to push the price up to $500+, so a dedicated bullet smoker might be cheaper if that’s all you need.  The tolerances on this grill is also not quite as tight as the egg, but I haven’t had a problem with it.  Some people have gone to extremes to insulate it from drafts but other than a little foil around the bottom damper I haven’t done anything. Just keep the top damper almost entirely close to avoid natural air flow from the heat, and the fan will control it.  With lump charcoal and some wood chunks it can go all night and more holding 225 dead on.

No fan needed for an Akorn, but a TipTopTemp is a must if you want to skip fiddling with the vents.

I was looking at that it but decided to go with the cheapest fan pid controller (no wifi).  Glad to hear it works well.

I bring it up to temp and as I approach 30F less than the smoking temp I start adjusting the TTT. I keep an eye on it until I dial it in. Typically from cold that takes 1/2 hour to an hour since I bring it up slow. After that it typically doesn’t require any adjustment unless it becomes windy and it wasn’t windy when you started. On those days it might vary 10F due to the wind and need to dial down.