For sure I’d say less is more. The only beer I’ve had it in was Stone’s Chocolate Mint Stout, which was out a year or two ago. The mint was very subtle, and while I wouldn’t have wanted any more mint, it was a pretty decent beer. I don’t know if I can think of another beer it would work in though. The roast of a stout keeps it in check.
I’ve always read that if you plant mint, you should keep it confined to a container or it’ll spread like a mother. Better organize a mojito party my friend!
Elysian did a saison with mint as a conference beer for the NHC in Seattle. It was good, although I thought the mint was very subdued. I also had a mint stout made by Anacortes Brewing years ago, the mint there was pretty strong and the beer was just ok. It might have been better if it had been a bit more chocolately.
If I were you I would make some mint extract by soaking leaves in vodka, then dose it into some sample beers to get a feel for how much mint you like (and if you like the pairing at all).
I made a spearmint mead about 3 years ago… It was awful… Good thing I still have like 4.5 gallons of it. It’s not fusel alcohols but the mint def enhances the alcohol to make it seem like some high proof stuff. It was a pretty sweet meet with a FG of roughly 1.030 but still… Mint just effects other flavors around it that I don’t find it appealing when combined with alcohol.
wow, that’s too bad. I make a spearmint and lime (Mojito) mead that is insanely good. got 3 medals with it as well - judges have really loved - it 40-45 pt score range.
I saw a mint chocolate stout from some company the other day - maybe that is a direction you want to go?
I bet it was the Stone I mentioned. It’s the only one I’ve seen. I thought the chocolatey stout kept the mint pretty well in check. It worked better than I thought it would.
haha yeah I’ll admit I have not used it since the spearmint mead… and I have not had a mint beer that i’ve enjoyed more than a sip of… but I eat mints like they are candy… go figure.
Just because you like a particular flavor doesn’t necessarily mean that flavor belongs in a beer. In the book, I use the example of a red wine Dijon mustard celery beer…