I don’t think it would taste like crap, but I dunno if Simcoe would be tops on my list for a wheat beer. It’s one of those hops that makes every beer taste like an IPA to me. I don’t think it would taste bad, but maybe more like an APA than a hoppy wheat beer. I’d lean towards something like Amarillo, Centennial or Mosaic to pair with the Citra. That’s just personal taste, though.
Good point. I have all of the above as well so I can sub in Amarillo for Simcoe (I am not a big Simcoe user so I have a pound I bought and am now looking to use up).
I brewed an IPA recently that was an equal mix, I think, of wheat, munich, and 2-row with simcoe and chinook in the boil, dry hopped with cascade and glacier. It was pretty tasty.